How to create your own tasting sheet?
Quick answer
A good tasting sheet has five sections: wine ID (name, vintage, region), appearance (colour, intensity), nose (intensity, aromas), palate (sweetness, acidity, tannin, body, finish), and your conclusion (score, would you buy it again?). Keep it on one side of A5 paper with tick boxes for speed and blank space for personal notes.
Detailed answer
Creating your own tasting sheet is one of the most rewarding wine projects you can do, and it takes about 30 minutes. The goal is to build a tool that works for you -- not a bureaucratic form that slows you down.
Start with the header: wine name, producer, region/appellation, grape variety, vintage, alcohol percentage, price, and date tasted. This metadata is critical for tracking your taste evolution over months and years.
For appearance, keep it simple. A colour strip (pale-medium-deep), a hue indicator (lemon/gold/amber for whites, ruby/garnet/brick for reds), and a clarity checkbox. Some people add a small empty circle where they colour in the actual shade with a pencil -- surprisingly useful when flipping back through old notes.
The nose section works best as a grid: aroma families (fruity, floral, spicy, earthy, oaky) down the left side, intensity levels (none, light, medium, pronounced) across the top. Check the boxes and jot specific aromas in the margin. Leave space for first nose (before swirling) and second nose (after).
The palate section is where scales shine. Rate sweetness, acidity, tannin, body, and finish on a 1-5 scale. Add a line for balance (are the components in harmony?) and one for complexity. A spider/radar diagram is a brilliant visual shortcut -- draw a pentagon with each axis representing one element and connect the dots.
Finish with your conclusion: an overall score (use whatever scale you like), a 2-3 line free-text comment, a drinkability window (drink now / hold 2-5 years / hold 5-10 years / hold 10+), and the most honest question of all: 'Would I buy this again?' Yes, no, or at a lower price.
Pro tip: print your sheets on A5 card stock, one side only. Punch holes and keep them in a binder organised by region or date. Or go digital with a spreadsheet that mirrors your layout.
| Section | Elements to include | Recommended format |
|---|---|---|
| Identification | Name, producer, vintage, grape, price | Text fields |
| Appearance | Colour, intensity, clarity | Colour strip + checkboxes |
| Nose | Aroma families, intensity, specific aromas | Grid + free space |
| Palate | Sweetness, acidity, tannin, body, finish | 1-5 scales or radar chart |
| Conclusion | Overall score, ageing, comments, rebuy? | Score + free text |