How to know if wine is still good?
Quick answer
To check if wine is still good, look at three things: colour (brown-tinged red or amber white signals advanced oxidation), smell (vinegar, wet cardboard, or bruised apple means trouble), and taste (no fruit and a flat finish confirm decline). A wine past its prime isn't harmful — just not enjoyable.
Detailed answer
Before you pour a questionable bottle for guests, here's a quick three-step check that any wine drinker can do. It takes about 30 seconds and can save you from serving something unpleasant.
Step 1 — Look at it. Pour a small amount and tilt the glass against a white background. A healthy red wine shows purple (if young) to garnet (if mature) hues. If the edge looks brown or brick-coloured and the wine is supposed to be young, that's oxidation. For whites, a deep gold or amber colour (unless it's a deliberately oxidative style like Vin Jaune) is a warning sign.
Step 2 — Smell it. This is where most faults reveal themselves. The big ones: vinegar smell (acetic acid from bacterial contamination), wet cardboard or musty basement (TCA cork taint — affects about 3–5 % of cork-sealed bottles), bruised apple or sherry-like notes (oxidation), and rotten eggs or struck match (reduction — this one can sometimes be fixed by decanting). If the wine smells clean and fruity, you're almost certainly fine.
Step 3 — Taste a sip. A faulty wine tastes sharp and vinegary, completely devoid of fruit, watery in texture, and finishes abruptly. A wine that's simply past its peak (but not faulty) tastes flat and dull — drinkable but not enjoyable.
One important note: crystals at the bottom of the bottle (tartrate) and sediment are NOT faults. Tartrate crystals are harmless and natural — sometimes called "wine diamonds." Sediment in old wine is actually a sign of quality. Just decant carefully and enjoy.
When in doubt, trust your nose. If it smells off, it almost certainly tastes off. And remember: a bad wine won't hurt you — it just won't bring you any pleasure.
Identifying wine faults
| Sign | Likely fault | Reversible? |
|---|---|---|
| Vinegar smell | Acetic acid spoilage | No |
| Wet cardboard / musty | Cork taint (TCA) | No |
| Bruised apple / sherry | Oxidation | No |
| Rotten egg / struck match | Reduction | Yes (decanting) |
| Crystals / sediment | Not a fault | — |